On this page
A cold email that gets replies is short (under 100 words), specific to the business, about their problem rather than your service, and ends with an easy question. Personalise the first line, make one offer, and follow up twice.
Key takeaways
- One specific observation beats three paragraphs about you.
- Ask for a small yes: "Can I send you an example?"
- Plain text, no attachments, no images in the first email.
- Two or three polite follow-ups double your replies without being pushy.
The five-line structure
- Observation: something true and specific about their business.
- Consequence: what that costs them.
- Offer: what you do, in one sentence.
- Proof: a result or a similar client, briefly.
- Ask: a yes-or-no question with a low commitment.
Example: web design
Subject: Bookings for Smile Studio
Hi Dr Patel,
I noticed Smile Studio has great reviews but patients can only book by phone. After hours, those patients usually book with whoever lets them do it online.
I add online booking to clinic websites in about a week; a clinic in Dallas got 40 online bookings in its first month.
Would it be useful if I sent a short video of how it would look on your site?
Ahmed, BrightSites (address and opt-out below)
Example: local SEO
Subject: "Electrician in Bristol"
Hi Tom, when I search "electrician in Bristol", Spark & Co doesn't show in the map results, though you're 2 miles from the centre and have 4.8 stars.
I help trades get into those results with their Google profile and reviews. Can I send you the three changes I'd make first? No charge.
Subject lines that work
- The business name: "Riverside Plumbing website"
- A search they care about: "'Dentist in Leeds' results"
- A question: "Online booking for Glow Salon?"
Avoid hype, fake "Re:" or urgency you can't back up. Honest subject lines are also a legal requirement in several countries; see cold email rules.
Personalise in 60 seconds
Look at the business on Google Maps and their website or social page. Note one of: their review rating, a missing feature (booking, menu, prices), a recent photo, a competitor nearby. TierOneLeads exports include the website status, so you know before you look whether they have a site.
Follow-ups
- Day 3: "Just checking this reached you: happy to send the example."
- Day 7: share something useful: a quick tip, or the mock-up itself.
- Day 14: "I'll close the loop here. If online booking becomes a priority, I'm happy to help."
Stop after that, and stop immediately if they ask.
Measure and improve
Track sends, replies and positive replies per template. A good first target is a reply from 5 to 10 percent of well-targeted emails; below that, change the first line or the offer. Log everything in a simple pipeline.
Frequently asked questions
How long should a cold email be?
Under 100 words is a good target. Busy owners read the first two lines and decide.
How many follow-ups should I send?
Two or three, spaced a few days to a week apart, and none after someone asks you to stop.
What is a good reply rate for cold email?
For well-targeted, personalised emails to local businesses, 5 to 10 percent replies is a reasonable target to aim for.
TierOneLeads Editorial Team
Guides from the team behind TierOneLeads, written from what we see in 38 million Tier 1 business listings and from agencies and freelancers who sell to them.